Frequently Asked Questions
The short answer is no. Authors, illustrators, editors, or agents cannot serve in categories where a book is eligible that they worked directly on. Could you recuse yourself? Sure, but this goes beyond just not voting on your book. Just by being in the category, your presence can influence fellow judges. If a book was a finalist or winner in a category where the author was a judge, even with assurances that the author recused themself, it is a difficult situation for everyone.
That doesn't mean you can't be a judge! There are lots of category options open to you and where your expertise could be valuable! Just not the one where you have an eligible book.
If you have an indirect relationship with a book eligible for nomination, you can apply to be a judge. Round 1 only. It is imperative that you be as transparent as possible in the application and explain your less direct relationship (e.g., intern at the publisher but no direct connection to any eligible books, friends with the author, part of the author's writing group, etc). At the time you apply, we do not know what books will be nominated, so it is not cut and dry. Each situation is reviewed independently, but we can say for certain that you would recuse yourself from all discussions associated with the book.
We encourage you to apply to judge in another category. If your friend wrote a picture book and you love illustrated books, the Easy Reader/Early Chapter category may be a perfect option for you! If you are not sure what to do and want more details before you apply, contact us at info@cybils.com.